The warfare between inexperienced hydrogen and blue hydrogen has solely simply begun, however issues are already wanting not so good for blue hydrogen stakeholders. The most recent information comes from Hystar, a Norwegian startup that’s planning to construct a totally automated, 4-gigawatt electrolyzer manufacturing unit in Norway to grease the skids on the inexperienced hydrogen pipeline. The corporate hasn’t even begun building and it’s already planning to vault into North America with an much more bold scale-up.

Inexperienced Hydrogen Vs. Blue Hydrogen: Who Wore Sustainability Finest?

For these of you new to the subject, hydrogen is like water to fashionable industrialized economies: It touches all the pieces, they usually can’t reside with out it. Amongst different features, hydrogen is a gasoline and an enter for the refining, metallurgy and prescribed drugs industries. World meals methods additionally depend upon fertilizer produced with hydrogen.

Hydrogen extracted from pure fuel has been the first driver of all this exercise, with coal additionally factoring in to a lesser extent.

That’s about to alter because the falling value of wind, photo voltaic, and different renewables has flipped the script on electrolysis, a recognized expertise for pushing hydrogen fuel from plain water with {an electrical} present.

The result’s inexperienced hydrogen, a brand new world trade that has been drawing investor curiosity like honey to flies.

In distinction, so-named blue hydrogen is a public relations gimmick geared toward enabling fossil vitality stakeholders to go about their enterprise even because the planet burns.

Blue hydrogen merely refers back to the usual fossil-sourced hydrogen, tricked out with carbon seize methods. It doesn’t tackle the plethora of environmental points associated to pure fuel extraction — together with the affect on water sources — whereas including one other layer of impacts. Right here within the US, blue hydrogen proposals have already sparked protests over new pipelines and sequestration websites, and there’s loads extra the place that comes from.

Sparks Fly When Inexperienced Hydrogen Meets Automation

Contemplating the highly effective personal sector and governmental forces in play (taking a look at you, Exxon), blue hydrogen is probably going to proceed attracting investor curiosity and public subsidies into the longer term, assuming there’s one. The massive query for blue hydrogen followers to reply is what to do with all their product. They should persuade industrial provide chains to proceed relying on fossil inputs when customers up the worth chain are clamoring for inexperienced options.

Good luck with that. In the meantime, firms like Hystar are pushing the inexperienced hydrogen provide chain by driving down the price of electrolysis methods.

For Hystar, automation is the secret.”Hystar’s PEM electrolysers are essentially the most environment friendly and most secure on the planet and have been designed for mass manufacturing from the very starting,” the corporate explains, with PEM referring to the proton trade membrane expertise extensively utilized in electrolyser methods.

“The ultra-efficient design, which is patented and distinctive to Hystar, boasts a 90% thinner membrane than standard electrolysers, enabling the manufacturing of as much as 150% extra inexperienced hydrogen,” they add.

Many Palms Come Collectively For Sustainable H2

The automation-based marketing strategy has gotten an help from the Analysis Council of Norway, which has supported Hystar’s “Autostack” electrolyser manufacturing program below a three-year industrial initiative.

“The purpose of the Autostack challenge is to develop a whole industrialization idea for high-volume manufacturing of PEM electrolyser stacks,” explains SINTEF, an unbiased analysis heart primarily based in Norway. Additionally collaborating in Autostack together with SINTEF are Semcon Sweden AB and Tronrud Engineering.

“The present cutting-edge manufacturing strategies are low-volume and primarily based on guide processes. Mass manufacturing is critical, not solely to make the zero-emission inexperienced hydrogen cost-competitive with the CO2 intensive gray hydrogen manufacturing strategies but in addition to satisfy the anticipated future demand for electrolysers,” SINTEF notes.

That’s not so simple as it sounds. Automating the PEM electrolyzer manufacturing course of is a difficult enterprise characterised by a excessive diploma of precision. “Every cell consists of ultrathin elements which should be assembled with very excessive necessities on positioning and alignment,” SINTEF notes. “That is additional challenged by every cell part having demanding traits, comparable to being brittle or floppy.”

The thought seems to have caught on amongst buyers. Final January Hystar introduced a brand new spherical of $26 million in Collection B funding for its automated electrolyzer manufacturing expertise.

Co-helmed by the hydrogen-centric agency AP Ventures and Mitsubishi Company, the money infusion was geared toward accelerating Hystar’s purpose for delivering electrolysis methods within the vary of 100 megawatts or extra.

“Extra buyers within the spherical included Finindus, Nippon Metal Buying and selling, Hillhouse Funding and Trustbridge Companions, alongside present buyers SINTEF Ventures and Firda,” Hyster famous, underscoring the function of the world metal trade in pushing the inexperienced hydrogen envelope.

“Hystar’s patented expertise is a game-changer in relation to tackling hard-to-abate sectors at scale, comparable to metal, ammonia, and heavy-duty transportation,” they emphasised. “The worldwide metal trade alone, for instance, would require 52 million tonnes of inexperienced hydrogen yearly to decarbonize by 2050.”

Look Out, North America

As for whether or not or not Hystar will convey its automated electrolyzer factories to the US, that’s query.

The outlook for public help for inexperienced hydrogen initiatives within the US dimmed when former US President Donald Trump was in workplace, although the Division of Vitality continued to fund R&D initiatives.

After Trump misplaced — sure, misplaced — the 2020 election to President Joe Biden, the Vitality Division turned up the warmth on different hydrogen sourcing with a brand new $8 billion funding pot to determine a community of 8-10 “clear” hydrogen hubs across the US. Blue hydrogen is within the combine (it’s stipulated within the Bipartisan Infrastructure legislation, which supplied the funds), however the emphasis is on inexperienced hydrogen.

A number of states have shaped consortia to compete for a share of the $8 billion. One area of in all probability curiosity to Hystar is the Northeast US, the place a beast of a hydrogen hub is forming. The area provides offshore wind sources, pleasant state insurance policies, and entry to European markets as promoting factors. When you have one other guess drop us a notice within the remark thread.

Hystar expects to start work on a brand new 4-gigawatt, totally automated electrolyzer manufacturing unit in Høvik, Norway subsequent 12 months, with operation to start in 2025.

Subsequent 12 months Hystar additionally expects to select a spot within the North America to determine a second multi-gigawatt manufacturing unit. It’s presently in discussions with each Canada and the US, although Fredrik Mowill, CEO of Hystar, appeared to trace that the corporate is attracted by the Biden administration’s help for inexperienced hydrogen.

“As we proceed to scale up our operations, we are actually taking a look at alternatives past Europe – the North American market has created a extremely beneficial surroundings for firms like ours to thrive in,” Mowill stated in a press launch issued yesterday.

In the identical press launch, Hystar gave each the US and Canada props for supporting insurance policies that convey down the price of inexperienced hydrogen, in distinction to different governments.

“…the US has made bold hydrogen subsidies accessible by way of the Inflation Discount Act, with plans being developed for 10 main hydrogen hubs, whereas Canada is investing tax credit score accessible for clear hydrogen manufacturing,” Hystar defined.

On first learn, that assertion appears to point extra enthusiasm for the US. Nevertheless, Mowill additionally hinted that future circumstances could tip the stability.

“We’re wanting ahead to figuring out the best North American location for Hystar,” he added, which may very well be a veiled trace that Canada can be a super location if Trump and his MAGA Republicans strengthen their grip on US vitality coverage.

That depends upon the end result of the 2024 election cycle, so maintain on to your hats. Within the meantime, Hystar already expects that its North American operations could outstrip its footprint in Europe. They plan to start out scooping up expertise for his or her North American enterprise within the close to future, so control their recruitment adverts for a touch on the situation.

Comply with me tinamcasey on Bluesky, Threads, Submit, LinkedIn, and Spoutible.