Home BMW IIHS Provides BMW, Tesla and 9 Others, Automated Driving Programs Low Rankings

IIHS Provides BMW, Tesla and 9 Others, Automated Driving Programs Low Rankings

IIHS Provides BMW, Tesla and 9 Others, Automated Driving Programs Low Rankings


In a latest complete analysis by the Insurance coverage Institute for Freeway Security (IIHS), the efficiency of semi-autonomous driving methods from a number of automakers was scrutinized beneath a brand new set of testing standards geared toward bettering highway security and lowering the misuse of such applied sciences. This new evaluation lined 14 semi-autonomous methods from 9 manufacturers, together with BMW’s Driving Assistant Professional (Degree 2 functionalities), GM’ Tremendous Cruise, Ford’s BlueCruise, and Tesla’s Autopilot.

14 Automakers Have been Examined

BMW 7 Sequence with Degree 3 proven right here

Regardless of the varied array of applied sciences examined, a staggering 11 methods have been unable to satisfy the IIHS’s stringent necessities, incomes a “Poor” score. Lexus’ Teammate system with Superior Drive was the one know-how to safe an “Acceptable” score. In the meantime, GM’s Tremendous Cruise and Nissan’s ProPilot Help with Navi-link obtained “Marginal” scores, standing out for his or her respective strengths in security options and cooperative steering. BMW’s Driving Assistant Professional obtained a score of “Good” in Lane Change and Cooperative Steering, “Acceptable” within the Driver Monitoring and Security Options, “Poor” in Consideration Reminders and Adaptive Cruise Management (ACC) Resume. The total rating is right here.

It’s vital to make clear that these automobiles don’t provide totally autonomous driving capabilities; relatively, they require drivers to stay vigilant, maintaining a tally of the highway and overseeing the system’s operation. Drivers should be ready to imagine guide management of the car in case of any points. Moreover, these methods shouldn’t be confused with what are historically generally known as superior driver-assistance methods (ADAS). The IIHS categorizes ADAS as applied sciences that improve car security by options akin to computerized emergency braking, blind spot detection, and lane departure prevention. BMW provides ADAS in a wide range of automobiles, together with however not restricted to i5, i7, iX, X5. This yr, the BMW 7 Sequence will obtain a Degree 3 ADAS in Europe.

A spokesperson for BMW of North America highlighted the novelty of those requirements from the IIHS, mentioning the absence of homologated requirements for such methods. The spokesperson additionally famous that the present analysis closely emphasizes driver monitoring and alert mechanisms, areas the place many methods confirmed inadequacies in accordance with the IIHS’s standards. Full assertion might be seen on the finish of the article.

Testing Procedures

IIHS says that their new testing routine is multifaceted, specializing in driver monitoring, consideration reminders, emergency procedures, driver involvement, and important security options akin to seatbelt engagement earlier than system activation. These classes intention to make sure that semi-autonomous methods improve, relatively than detract from, general highway security, notably with a rising concern over pedestrian fatalities.

The IIHS employed varied methods to check the restrictions of those semi-automated methods, akin to masking the driving force’s head with a cheesecloth to dam their face from the car’s inside cameras and sensors, and affixing ankle weights to the steering wheel to imitate the presence of a driver’s fingers. IIHS can also be proposing a check that may determine when a foam block the dimensions of a mobile phone is being utilized by the driving force.

BMW X1 Was Examined By IIHS

The Driving Assistant Professional system within the 2024 BMW X1 has two distinct functionalities based mostly on the velocity of the automobile. BMW of North America says in an announcement that IIHS’s analysis of the X1 targeted solely on a single facet of its Driving Help Skilled system, particularly the “hands-on” function lively at speeds above roughly 40 mph. This function, which depends completely on steering wheel sensor inputs, goals to help the driving force by lowering fatigue with out providing full “hands-off” capabilities.

Conversely, the “hands-off” Site visitors Jam Assistant operates beneath about 40 mph to alleviate driver stress in dense site visitors by autonomously steering, braking, and accelerating. This mode does interact an instrument panel-mounted digicam to make sure the driving force’s consideration stays on the highway, as bodily contact with the steering wheel isn’t required.

Testing Standardization Is Mandatory

Except for the attention-grabbing findings, the check underscores a important problem that surpasses even technical limitations: the inconsistency in ADAS philosophies throughout automobile manufacturers, particularly across the situations for disengagement and the alert strategies. This threat turns into notably vital in situations the place a family owns a number of automobiles geared up with differing methods. Due to this fact, there’s a want for standardization and clear pointers throughout the automobile business with reference to developments in driving help applied sciences.


  • Lexus Teammate with Superior Drive, 2022-24 Lexus LS


  • GM Tremendous Cruise, 2023-24 GMC Sierra
  • Nissan ProPilot Help with Navi-Hyperlink, 2023-24 Nissan Ariya


  • BMW Energetic Driving Assistant Professional, 2023-24 BMW X1
  • Tesla Autopilot Model 2023.7.10, 2021-23 Tesla Mannequin 3
  • Tesla Full Self Driving (Beta) Model 2023.7.10, 2023-23 Tesla Mannequin 3
  • Mercedes-Benz Energetic Distance Help Distronic with Energetic Steering Help, 2022-23 Mercedes-Benz C-Class
  • Lexus Dynamic Radar Cruise Management with Lane Tracing Help, 2022-24 Lexus LS
  • Ford Adaptive Cruise Management with Cease & Go and Lane Centering Help, 2021-24 Ford Mustang Mach-E
  • Ford BlueCruise, 2021-24 Ford Mustang Mach-E
  • Genesis Freeway Driving Help 2, 2023-24 Genesis G90
  • Genesis Good Cruise Management/Lane Following Help, 2023-24 Genesis G90
  • Nissan ProPilot Help 2.0, 2023-24 Nissan Ariya
  • Volvo Pilot Help, 2022-24 Volvo S90

Assertion from BMW issued to media:

“We respect and recognize the efforts of the IIHS to problem our business to make higher, safer automobiles, however sometimes we differ philosophically about easy methods to do sure issues – on this case, how driver help methods ought to monitor driver consideration and in what conditions.

The check performed by the IIHS within the BMW X1 lined just one perform of 1 driver help system. The Driving Help Skilled system within the X1 has each “hands-on” and a “hands-off” performance. The “hands-on” perform, which is what was examined, works at speeds over ~40 mph. It solely considers enter from sensors within the steering wheel, which we really feel is ample given its meant goal. It isn’t meant to be a completely “hands-off” system. It’s a partly automated system meant to assist the driving force by lowering fatigue. In our testing, we have now not seen a transparent benefit in turning on the driving force monitoring digicam.

The “hands-off” perform (Site visitors Jam Assistant) solely works at low speeds (beneath ~40 mph) when site visitors situations permit. It’s meant to minimize stress and fatigue in high-traffic conditions by steering, braking, and accelerating mechanically. This perform does use the digicam mounted within the instrument panel to observe driver consideration as a result of it doesn’t require the driving force to the touch the steering wheel. However the car should be capable of verify the driving force is retaining his or her eyes on the highway to observe the site visitors scenario.

BMW Freeway Assistant, a more moderen, extra subtle system obtainable within the 5 Sequence, 7 Sequence, and different higher-end BMW fashions, delivers prolonged “hands-off” driving at freeway speeds. Once more, as a result of it doesn’t require the driving force to the touch the steering wheel, it does make the most of the digicam to observe driver consideration. Whereas we consider we provide secure and strong driver help methods, we will definitely take into account the suggestions made on this report as these methods proceed to evolve.”



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here